“Tangible paradise depends on beginner’s mind, on a broken heart, and on the living earth on which we stand.”
It was a clear November day on Hawk Hill…just enough wind to keep the hawks moving through as we identified and counted them. We were being treated to gorgeous views of lots of adult Red-tailed Hawks in beautiful light. I was standing on the north platform, the best vantage for catching the birds as they materialized in front of us, circling and gaining height on the thermals before heading south over the Golden Gate. It was a good day; not many visitors to the hill, so it was quiet, and I could listen in on the conversation between the guru hawk watchers who practically live on the north platform during the fall migration season.
We’d spotted a set of three hawks riding the thermals and getting closer; two red-taileds and something strange (which always gets hearts racing on hawk hill). The strange shape turned out to be another Red-tailed Hawk after all, but it had a broken wing. I don’t know how it could still fly, but it did, flapping more frequently than the other hawks to keep itself aloft and on track.
All three birds approached, close in to the hill. My memory is of watching the hawk with the broken wing for a long time in my binoculars, and that the usual expert chatter on the north platform died away. I remember feeling very reverent about something very big that felt very tangible. All over the planet, numberless animals were moving south on the great energy of migration. And this hawk with a broken wing moved with it, too; it was perfectly at place in the world. Its struggle did not seem like a struggle at all; it was life.
It was the most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen.
Wendy Johnson spoke at Stone Creek a few weeks ago; I brought her book to have her sign, and I thought about what I might ask her if I had the chance. In a section of the book called “Beauty Counts”, she lovingly relates a story of a woman consumed by grief, and that quote about “tangible paradise” appears at the end of that story. I didn’t know what my question was, but I wanted to ask something about that quote. I think I wanted to resist…”But WHY? Why does tangible paradise have to require a broken heart?” Because I don’t want to have a broken heart any more. I’m tired of feeling broken altogether. I’m tired of feeling like mush inside, mush surrounding a giant gaping hole of pain and want. I’m weary of every good mood being followed by a broken-winged crash.
It turns out that her talk (available as an MP3 here) included that very story of the woman in grief. I still don’t know why we need to be broken, but I realize that it is a deep truth. Lately I feel that my biggest problem is simply surrendering to what is. I am not in control. Migration season does not stop for a broken wing. Nor are we any less a part of life for our brokeness.
Wendy closed her talk by telling us, “Leave the wind to the wind and the flowers to the flowers. And be yourself. Be a fully alive, awake, ready, broken human being.”
What else can we be?